No, there is no harm in it, even eating donkey meat is not haram; it is makruh. It is makruh because it has critical importance in daily life and during the war. The fact that always having horses and donkeys on hand made Muslims strong. For this reason, they said it was makruh, but it was still not called haram.
Muslim Turks in Central Asia eat horses because they have not gone to extremes; the fatwa was taken to an extreme here; it was accepted as haram.
Horses and donkeys are animals as clean as sheep and cows, their meat is clean, and they are no longer a means of warfare and an indispensable part of daily life, so food is not even makruh, and their milk is not haram.
Are zebras eaten? Can some deer species be eaten larger than a donkey, almost as much as a horse? Why don’t a donkey or horse be eaten if they are eaten?
Biologically, is there any difference between them in terms of cleanliness? Does anyone die because of eating horse or donkey meat? Has it been determined that the cause of an incurable disease is eating horse or donkey meat?
Right now, if a person sets up a horse or donkey farm in Turkey or anywhere in the world, feeds and sells them for their meat and milk, no one can stop him and say, “You are doing something illegal.” No one can say “you are eating haram” to those who buy products from it and eat it.
The state system cannot prevent such entrepreneurs. If I were the state’s official head, I would immediately ensure that horse and donkey farms become widespread. I would immediately remove the state incentives given to pig farms and gave those support to horse, donkey, zebra, and deer farms.
In this regard, it have to be noted that in all four madhhabs, those who say “halal” rather than “haram” are in the majority.
In the Hanafi school, Imam Azam had two great students. Imam Abu Yusuf and Imam Muhammad, his two great students in the office of ijtihad, did not even say it was makruh as they did not say haram. They said mubah. These two imams are called “imameyn,” and if the ijtihad of Imam Azam is different in an issue and the ijtihad of the imameyn is different, the fatwa is given according to the imameyn. The “true” muftis must understand these parts thoroughly and guide Muslims in every period. Also, when it is said makruh, there is the question of whether it is tanzihen, that is, makruh, which is close to halal, or whether it is makruh, tahrimen, that is, close to haram.
Those who belong to the Hanafi sect and say makruh for horse meat say it is tanzihen makruh, that is, makruh, which is close to halal. When we look at the hadiths accepted as a source/source in this regard, It is understood that our Prophet (PBUH)forbade eating the meat by slaughtering a horse during the war. Fatwas are different during the campaign/war, but in regular times, fatwas are various.
In the section “Can you eat a donkey,” everyone held back even more and still does it. This is something that scientists should not do. Of course, they must have a fear of Allah SWT, and there will be no willingness to give fatwas, but when they hold back too much due to the fear of the plague, things get so complicated, and there is no consensus on the right fatwas and deeds for centuries.
Donkey meat is also halal, and it is also halal to eat the flesh of mules, which are a combination of donkeys and horses. Because the meat of the animal, which consists of the variety of the breed of the animal, both of which are halal to eat, is also halal.
It should also be noted that many scholars forbade eating the meat of domesticated horses and donkeys. As I wrote from the beginning, such fatwas were given by calculating the balances in the lives of Muslims, and our Prophet (PBUH) did not forbid eating untamed horses and donkeys, even during the war.
I’ve been saying the same things for over ten years. Some scholars gave fatwas based on some hadiths. Still, those hadiths forbid music sung by women, even half-naked women, accompanied by drinks and containing curses, insults, or religiously objectionable parts.
Considering these, many say that it is permissible to “play or listen to music within limits”, from the great Ahl as-Sunnah scholars and even the true murshids. Just as all kinds of music are not haram under all circumstances, we are not prohibited from eating the meat of horses and donkeys and drinking their milk under any circumstances. For those who follow the Hanafi sect, it is permissible to eat the meat and drink the milk of horses and donkeys, whether domestic or wild, raised in nature or on farms.
As for the other three madhhabs… Now, it is necessary to be realistic in this matter and to discuss whether these three true sects in practice are among the sects that are now forgotten and have disappeared.
For centuries, no true scholars have followed the true mujtahid imams of these madhhabs. I surpassed the Maliki and Hanbali ones, even those who follow the Shafi’i sect today are in a deadlock, clearly faltering in front of their eyes. Because even if they need genuine imams within the sect and muftis in the authority of fatwa who have been followed by the true sect they follow, even if a worldwide search is done, there is no “genuine” one among the scholars in question. Although he knows how deficient he is, some pretend to be in the authority but are not even useful to themselves.
The jurisprudence of these three sects in the sources/records and whether the available part is enough to keep these sects alive and to assume them to be discussed.
According to reliable sources, it is permissible for Shafi’i, Hanbali, and Malikis to eat horse meat or drink its milk. It is acceptable, that is, it is allowed to do that job/thing; if you do it, it means that there is no reward or sin/punishment. In its clearer form, it means that eating horse meat has neither merit nor sin.
As a result, for centuries, Muslims worldwide have been worried and refrained from eating horses, donkeys, mules, zebras, and many other animals. However, the sect imams had already given the necessary fatwas that there was no harm in eating them, and people recorded those fatwas. For centuries, the “wrongful” backsliding and “overdoing” on these issues did not benefit the Muslims but harmed them. Even in many complex/unfavorable geographies, horses, donkeys, mules, zebras, and similar animals could be farmed, and this behavior could provide vital benefits in many “difficult, semi-arid” periods. There will be difficult and semi-arid or arid periods and geographies before us. Understanding these issues correctly, even now, will be very beneficial.
I think Iblis had very “sneaky” games in this regard. He also caused scholars to be haunted a lot, causing them to fall into delusions. He did his best and ensured that while there were so many clean, edible, healthy, meat and milk useful animals, the whole world was filled with pig farms that are the source of filth and disease.
Pigs, and therefore pig farms, are the source of many physical and spiritual diseases that plague the people of the world today.
When there are such clean animals, it can be understood that very insidious games are played by both the devil and the Dajjal simultaneously so that people eat pigs. However, there are other shocking truths that the world’s humanity must immediately fall upon. In the world, breeds of cows and sheep have recently been genetically manipulated.
Various names have been given to the cow and sheep species in question, and these breeds have spread rapidly from the western realm, which is under the control of the devil and the Dajjal, to the eastern realm, and they are still spreading even more.
Also, games are played over the masons who have taken control of the states by portraying them as supposedly scientific decisions and decisions that are compatible with medicine, by reason and logic. In this way, the rapid spread of the aforementioned later-derived genera was achieved.
However, the genetic codes were insidiously tampered with in these later derived genera. They have even added pig genes to them.
On the one hand, they wanted to be resistant to filth like pigs, to their manure, not to get sick all the time, and to reduce losses, but on the other hand, they targeted the human communities that they could not dehumanize because they could not make them consume pigs.
At the same time, they intended to harm the health of people who eat their meat and drink their milk from these animals.
Animals from these later derived breeds are also given all sorts of so-called vaccines throughout their lives.
It is said that these so-called vaccines are for the health of animals, but a state administration that has been taken out of freemason, Jewish, and satanist control and taken from the hands of traitors needs to do a “fair” study.
What exactly is aimed at animals of these breeds, and to what level are they meant?
What happens in those animals’ bodies, meat, and genes when it comes to so-called vaccines?
What happens in the bodies of those who eat them, drink the milk that is milked from them, or consume dairy products made from the milk in question?
These should be searched and investigated without losing a moment so that this “wild” time when every corner is a hospital and every house is full of patients will come to an end.
There is a high protein in the meat of horses and zebras that grow freely in the pasture or in nature and can move and run as much as they want. It will be a very accurate decision to feed zebra meat, especially to children. The meat of zebras, raised without binding, freely, and under healthy conditions, is healthier, more nutritious, and has more protein than cow meat.
Also, spreading rabbit meat and feeding the meat of rabbits that were raised by moving as much as they want in the pasture or in nature and eating healthy will be a breaking point. It will be one of the reasons for humanity to restore its health from head to toe. Rabbit meat also has high protein.
On the other hand, they have examined pork meat countless times, revealing that it is not clean and harmful to health. Just as homosexuals are ignoring the spread of AIDS, the states in the hands of the mason above, Jewish, and satanist rulers have also ignored that pork is harmful to health, and they do because both the antichrist and Iblis want them to act like this. Because this Ankebut Cult is an organization that is the enemy of humanity as an entire staff…
The meat of those deer, which is full of high protein, is a complete source of healing… Deer milk, which is also relatively high in protein, is also a source of healing. If desired, deer farms in many parts of the world would be full. Their meat, milk, skin, and horns were evaluated separately. As it became more widespread, its prices would decrease, benefiting humanity. Of the Nordic countries, there would be countries that derive most of their annual income from deer. They would grow and sell to the world in abundance. They are always deliberately blocked. Even though it is shown that such things are being done and free, they are secretly and insidiously blocked in front of them. It is not allowed to spread.
Iblis just rushed to the side of Asian countries and left. My articles are translated by many people in the nations there. It is discussed that my writings affect my decisions. Iblis is casting spells on them collectively with his own hands so that they may not understand what I have written on this subject, they may misunderstand what I have written, so that they will lose their understanding, become suffocated, and let go of the subject. That Iblis who made things unbecoming be eaten…
And no matter what a person eats, what he eats affects both his body and soul. It has spiritual/metaphysical effects. When the time comes, if I have a lot of time, I will explain the metaphysical effects of the vanquished.
Mehmet Fahri Sertkaya | Akademi Dergisi